The first in a series. Watch the video from the run below.
Garth and I laced up our running shoes, picked a route across Denver, and set ourselves a simple rule: call ten pizza shops, order a pizza from each one by phone, run to pick it up, eat a slice, and run to the next. Five miles. Ten pizzas. One very full stomach.
We did it because we are pizza people now.
At Raynmaker, that is our whole focus. The pizza shop’s job is to make great pizza. Our job is to make ordering it great. That means a phone order that gets answered, gets it right, goes straight into the shop’s system, and leaves the guest feeling taken care of. And it has to be quick for the owner to set up and something they never have to babysit.
You cannot build the best pizza ordering experience from a conference room. So we went out and ordered pizza the way everyone else does: by picking up the phone.
What happened when we called
Here is what ten phone orders across Denver sounded like.
- Some never answered. The phone rang out. That order, and that guest, went somewhere else.
- Some sent us away. We called to order and were told to use DoorDash or Uber Eats instead.
- At least three made us wait a minute or more before we could talk to anyone. A long recorded message, then another.
- A few asked us to “push 2” to reach a person. Try that while you are running, or driving.
- One got my phone number wrong.
- One took the order, but it never made it into their system.
- One had an AI answer the phone. All it wanted to do was text me a link to an online ordering app. I called because I wanted to order by phone.
And the ones that picked up and took the order? They were fine. The people were friendly, the order was placed, and the pizza was waiting when we ran in.
That is the thing. Nobody was trying to give us a bad experience. Most of these shops are busy, short-staffed, and doing their best. The phone is just the part of the business that falls through the cracks.
The score: 5 out of 10
Add it all up and phone ordering across our ten shops was, at best, inconsistent. Collectively, a 5 out of 10. Every order left us wanting it to be better.
The pizza did better. A few were real standouts. The rest were good, and honestly, pretty similar to each other.
That second part matters more than it sounds. When the pizza down the street tastes a lot like yours, the experience of ordering it is what people remember. The shop that answers on the first ring, takes the order right, and has it ready when they said it would be is the shop you call next Friday. The one that sent you to a recording, a keypad, or a delivery app is the one you forget.
And a lot of pizza gets ordered on the move. From the car on the way home. Walking out of practice with the kids. Between meetings. A minute-long greeting and “push 2 for an associate” do not work when your hands are on the wheel. Every one of those calls is a guest who wanted to give that shop their money, and a phone that made it hard.
What a 10 out of 10 sounds like
Somewhere around mile four, with pizza number eight in hand, Garth and I started describing the call we wished we had gotten. It is not complicated.
- Answered on the first ring. Every time, including at 6:45 on a Friday.
- No preamble. Straight to “What can we get started for you?”
- A real conversation. I can change my mind, ask what is good, and interrupt without starting over.
- It gets it right. The order is read back, my number is right, and it lands in the shop’s system the moment I say yes.
- It knows me the second time. “Your usual large pepperoni?”
- It tells me the truth about time. If they are slammed, say so, and tell me when it will really be ready.
- A text to confirm it, so I can stop thinking about it and get back to running.
That is the phone order every pizza shop deserves to offer, and the one every guest deserves to get. It is what we are building at Raynmaker, so the people making the pizza can keep their hands in the dough.
Next stop: maybe your neighborhood
The run was fun. It was a beautiful day in Denver, the company was good, and we ate more pizza than two runners probably should.
It was also just the beginning. Our mission is to visit hundreds of pizza shops, order the way real guests order, and live pizza culture everywhere we can. Every run teaches us something about what guests want and what shop owners are up against. We will share all of it here, alongside the video.
Stay tuned for the next Pizza Run. It could be in a neighborhood near you.
Tell us where to run next. Know a shop with a phone order that deserves a 10? Or a city we have to visit? Drop it in the comments on the video.
Joe and Garth, Raynmaker. We are pizza people.